Cpt Makgotloe
senior forensic analyst in ABIS subsection, ballistic section, SAPS
Captain Makgotloe was a police officer whose role in handling evidence and crime scene procedures came under scrutiny during the Madlanga Commission. Testimony described him as the person who confirmed that investigators could enter a scene, and he was involved in statement-taking and the seizure of a workstation. He faced questions about ballistic conclusions linking bullets to a specific firearm, as well as about his communications with detectives regarding linkages between seized weapons and other crimes. The commission also heard that he attempted to retrieve a firearm’s serial number, and he was questioned about discrepancies he himself had highlighted in official reports. Allegations were raised that information about linkages may have come from individuals with connections to organised crime networks, though this remained unproven.
What the record shows (376 total claims — 93 substantive shown)
3 contradictions on the record
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-1c7f7c752d32A asserts he spoke about linkages (implying knowledge); B asserts he could not have known them—cannot both be true.
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-f918b4c5bdfbOne says he performed etching on the pistol; the other says he did not attend to etching—same act, mutually exclusive.
“Cpt Makgotloe reported that he performed etching on the 9 mm pistol but 'no number was found'”
“in the initial report, Capt Makgotloe not attended to etching or checking for serial number.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-727c1f20a980Same affidavit issuance attributed two different dates (14 Oct 2024 vs 24 May 2024), cannot both be true.
“Captain Makgotloe completed the ballistics analysis of the exhibits (firearms and cartridge cases) and issued a Section 212 affidavit dated 24 May 202”