Nathi Mthethwa

Nathi Mthethwa, a former Minister of Police, is a central figure in the Commission's inquiry into allegations of political interference in police investigations. Testimony described him as having pressured senior officers to halt the prosecution of a police official, Richard Mdluli, and instead pursue disciplinary proceedings, with instructions reportedly delivered both verbally and in writing. He was also accused of forcing the Inspector General of Intelligence to write a letter supporting a legal challenge. Additionally, the record indicates he was prepared to testify about the removal of Lt-Gen Mkhwanazi from office, though he never communicated his intention to appear. His name also surfaced in connection with an alleged trip to Kenya regarding CIA operations.

23 claims0 scheme(s)1 contradiction(s)

What the record shows (23 total claims — 8 substantive shown)

1 contradiction on the record

◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness

NLI-6471fee216f4

A says he expressed intention to come to Commission; B says he never communicated that intention—directly opposed on same fact.

Day 35Brown Mogotsi“Yes, he did. He did tell me. He never said he made contact. He was just saying he is coming, he is prepared to come to the Commission and give that.”

Day 35Adv Chaskalson SC“ex-Minister Mthethwa at no stage communicated his intention to come to the Commission.”