WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language
other2021-06-22 – 2021-06-24E000284

Exhibit transport and registration irregularities for 541kg cocaine

Witness accounts detail the movement of the 541kg cocaine exhibits from Isipingo to Port Shepstone, with disputed SAP13 registration, instructions from Colonel Jacob, and failure to properly book exhibits in/out.

Described by 2 witnesses
Warrant Officer Mpangaseday 142Lieutenant-Colonel Justice Jabulani Duma (SAday 142
Each of these people gave first-hand evidence about this event. Several accounts of the same event is a property of the record — it is not verification, and witnesses can be mistaken together.
77 claims from testimony
"it is in line with the Port Shepstone stream"
scopeWarrant Officer MpangaseAdv SikhakhaneCL0152218
"a container that was containing approximately 7 to 8 kilograms of Cocaine"
containsMbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152267
"suspected to be at CHS Depot, Isipingo"
locationMbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152268
"I was under the impression that drugs were long transported to forensic science laboratory, Pretoria"
believedWarrant Officer MpangaseMbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152280
"I do not know who broke into the Port Shepstone storage"
characterisationWarrant Officer MpangaseMbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152282
"containers that were suspected of being used to smuggle 27 kilograms of Cocaine at CHC Container Depot."
containsBrigadier DumaCL0152412
"paragraph 3 of your statement, the last sentence you refer to 7 to 8 kilogrammes of Cocaine"
containsAdv SikhakhaneCL0152418
"Jacob and Sibiya and everyone that has come before the Commission referred to 27 kilogrammes"
amount zarAdv SikhakhaneCL0152419
"That was given to us by the CI operation initially. Before this one."
amount zarWarrant Officer Mbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152422
"Yes."
occurred onWarrant Officer Mbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152423
"28 kilogrammes of Cocaine that you are to engage in an operation in relation to."
scopeAdv SikhakhaneCL0152460
"Yes."
scopeWarrant Officer Mbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152461
"There was no plan in place."
natureWarrant Officer Mbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152462
"Yes."
action takenWarrant Officer Mbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152494
"No, it is not so."
action takenLt-Col (now Col) Gavin JacobWarrant Officer Mbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152495
"Jacob has come and said, he took that decision."
stated intentionLt-Col (now Col) Gavin JacobAdv SikhakhaneCL0152503
"moving them from the depot to Isipingo"
action takenChairpersonCL0152504
"Sergeant Mkhize and I were requested to assist with loading these bags into our vehicle and conveying them to Isipingo SAP."
action takenAdv Baloyi SCCL0152544
"All four of them say they were brought in to and helped with taking these bags onto their vehicle, drove with you to Isipingo police station, these things were offloaded at Isipingo and then they left to go and carry on with their functions"
stated viewAdv Baloyi SCCL0152554
"he says he was reminded"
stated viewLt-Col (now Col) Gavin JacobAdv SikhakhaneCL0152570
"Colonel Jacob must have had some discussion around the events at Isipingo"
action takenLt-Col (now Col) Gavin JacobAdv SikhakhaneCL0152571
"informing that Crime Intelligence has contacted him regarding a container at Isipingo, which might have drugs and that he was proceeding there with Lieutenant-Colonel Jacob and Warrant Officer Sibiya, all from Durban Serious Organised Crime"
action takenWarrant Officer MpangaseAdv SikhakhaneCL0152578
"That we were going to put the drugs in Isipingo’s police station."
stated intentionWarrant Officer MpangaseCL0152599
"the exhibits, were going to be stored at Isipingo police station?"
stated intentionAdv SikhakhaneCL0152600
"Yes, that is so."
believedWarrant Officer MpangaseWarrant Officer MpangaseCL0152601
"I was instructed by Colonel Jacob that we should book the out and transport them to Port Shepstone."
action takenLt-Col (now Col) Gavin JacobWarrant Officer MpangaseCL0152604
"had you then had some experience about entering suspected drug exhibits in the SAPS13 register?"
experienceWarrant Officer MpangaseAdv SikhakhaneCL0152617
"Yes, I had."
experienceWarrant Officer MpangaseWarrant Officer MpangaseCL0152618
"you were to leave the exhibits at Isipingo"
intentionWarrant Officer MpangaseAdv SikhakhaneCL0152631
"Yes, it is like that."
intentionWarrant Officer MpangaseWarrant Officer MpangaseCL0152632
"the exhibit official at Isipingo"
roleWarrant Officer PerumalAdv SikhakhaneCL0152634
"we were dealing with the events at Isipingo Police Station and your interaction with Warrant Officer Perumal"
subject matterIsipingo Police StationAdv SikhakhaneCL0152693
"When the time arrived that he needed to leave, he actually handed over to me that I needed to go with the people to Port Shepstone to transport those goods. He then asked me to open the inquiry"
stated viewWarrant Officer MpangaseWarrant Officer MpangaseCL0152696
"you went back to Port Shepstone DPCI, well, Port Shepstone Police Station and DPCI offices on the 23rd and the 24th"
locationWarrant Officer MpangaseAdv Baloyi SCCL0152729
"Yes"
locationWarrant Officer MpangaseWarrant Officer MpangaseCL0152730
"he left from Isipingo Police Station"
locationLt-Col (now Col) Gavin JacobAdv Baloyi SCCL0152746
"If I remember correctly"
believedWarrant Officer MpangaseWarrant Officer MpangaseCL0152758
"You entered the exhibits in the SAP13"
action takenWarrant Officer MpangaseAdv Baloyi SCCL0152776
"the exhibits were not going to FSL, they were going to Port Shepstone"
locationAdv Khumalo SCCL0152784
"That is clearly misleading"
characterisationAdv Khumalo SCCL0152787
"you all knew that these exhibits were going to Port Shepstone at the DPCI office"
locationAdv Khumalo SCCL0152791
"In my mind I thought I will put a statement and put the chain of events indicating how it happened from Port Shepstone"
thoughtWarrant Officer MpangaseWarrant Officer Mbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152793
"from the period these exhibits are booked in and out of Isipingo Police Station to the time when you do the entry in the Port Shepstone SAP13, SAPS has no record of where these drugs are or where these exhibits are"
action takenSouth African Police ServiceAdv Khumalo SCCL0152796
"the people who were also present at Port Shepstone did see that we were putting them into the storage"
locationWarrant Officer Mbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152799
"I remember there was an arrangement containing SAP13 register, where the exhibit clerk from Port Shepstone arrived"
stated viewWarrant Officer MpangaseWarrant Officer Mbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152828
"when the exhibits were stored at the Port Shepstone offices of DPCI on the 22nd, there was no SAP13 register entry on that day"
entry numberSAPS13 registerAdv Khumalo SCCL0152832
"Why did you not arrange for an SAP13 clerk from Port Shepstone on the 22nd itself to come and enter these exhibits"
action takenWarrant Officer MpangaseAdv Baloyi SCCL0152841
"I presume that because of the fact that we have already stored them in the Port Shepstone, there was no necessity that we register them on SAP13 in Isipingo – Port Shepstone, by the way"
stated reasonWarrant Officer MpangaseWarrant Officer Mbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152844
"the protocol or the national instruction requires that exhibits must be recorded in SAP13"
requirementAdv Baloyi SCCL0152845
"we had already recorded them in SAP13 in Isipingo"
recorded inWarrant Officer Mbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152848
"they were being transported to Port Shepstone"
transported toWarrant Officer Mbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0152849
"I did not know that I am required to put them in SAP13"
knowledgeWarrant Officer MpangaseAdv Baloyi SCCL0152857
"we are required on SAP13 that we must enter"
stated viewWarrant Officer MpangaseWarrant Officer MpangaseCL0152879
"now they are moving to Port Shepstone"
transported toWarrant Officer MpangaseCL0152880
"taking them out of SAP13 register"
action takenWarrant Officer MpangaseCL0152881
"Port Shepstone register"
titleSAP13ChairpersonCL0152882
"Port Shepstone, indeed"
titleSAP13Warrant Officer MpangaseCL0152883
"we know you take them on the 24th out of the Port Shepstone police station register"
action takenAdv Baloyi SCCL0152884
"when the exhibit clerk came with SAP13"
action takenWarrant Officer MpangaseCL0152886
"my work at the exhibit office includes the processing and ensuring the safeguarding of property that is handed into the SAP13 at Port Shepstone"
responsibilityPort Shepstone Police Station exhibit clerkCL0152894
"I have knowledge of the entry made of exhibits under Port Shepstone SAP13"
knowledgePort Shepstone Police Station exhibit clerkCL0152895
"a large amount of Cocaine that was handed in by Detective Warrant Officer Mpangase of the Durban DPCI office"
action takenPort Shepstone Police Station exhibit clerkCL0152896
"he was not there when the entries were made on the SAP13"
observedAdv Baloyi SCCL0152900
"the person who brought the SAP13 register was the person who is employed there at Port Shepstone SAPS"
memberPort Shepstone Police StationWarrant Officer MpangaseCL0152903
"I later saw the entry made into the SAP13 in column 6"
observedPort Shepstone Police Station exhibit clerkCL0152910
"the entries that you made in the Port Shepstone SAP13, 3.1 to 3.31"
contentsSAP13Adv Khumalo SCCL0152922
"You enter the exhibits in the Port Shepstone SAP13 register"
contentsSAP13ChairpersonCL0152939
"you immediately book them out of that register"
contentsSAP13ChairpersonCL0152940
"you are experienced in working with the SAP13 register"
experienceWarrant Officer MpangaseChairpersonCL0152942
"you knew that the exhibits were going to remain at the DPCI office in Port Shepstone"
knowledgeWarrant Officer MpangaseAdv Khumalo SCCL0152955
"they have been taken out of the Port Shepstone SAP13 register."
stateChairpersonCL0152992
"he gave instructions on the 23rd, you say, you tell us that is what you say in your statement. You had instructions to go and put the stuff in exhibit bags, to enter them in the SAP13 to go and take samples"
gave instructionLt-Col (now Col) Gavin JacobAdv Baloyi SCCL0153009
"541"
countWarrant Officer Mbongeleni Felix Simangaliso MpangaseCL0153030
"I arranged with Port Shepstone Station that Warrant Officer Mpangase can enter all the Cocaine into the SAP13 and sign it out for further investigation, avoiding transporting all the Cocaine to the station due to the security risks and logistics involved"
stated viewWarrant Officer Van Den BergCL0153034
"I told the station the Cocaine was in the process of being moved to Cape Town and it just needed to be booked in and out for the purpose of the chain of custody"
stated viewWarrant Officer Van Den BergCL0153035
"in paragraph 16 of your statement, you say on the following day, which is the 23rd, Colonel Jacob called you to go and get FSL bags"
contentsAdv Baloyi SCCL0153040
"General Senona said, he said it is not true that you were retiring"
stated viewMaj-Gen SenonaAdv Baloyi SCCL0153059