WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language
other14 August 2026E000336

Carrim refuses an independent medical assessment

The basis on which Mr Carrim could be excused from appearing was an independent medical assessment. The Chairperson recorded that Mr Carrim was resisting being examined by an independent practitioner, had refused that it be done, and had instead offered his own specialists. Counsel for Mr Carrim described an alternative mechanism his side had proactively offered and undertook to cooperate if it were used.

7 claims from testimony
"he may only not appear today on the basis of an independent medical assessment"
condition for appearanceSuliman CarimAdv Hassim SCCL0180864
"Mr Carrim is resisting, strenuously so, to be examined by somebody who can actually challenge those reports"
resisting examinationSuliman CarimChairpersonCL0180983
"He has refused that that should be done"
refusedSuliman CarimChairpersonCL0180994
"for Mr Carrim to offer us his specialists"
offeredSuliman CarimChairpersonCL0180996
"if they are going to be used, we will cooperate to the extent that we can"
stated intentionSuliman CarimMr PremhidCL0181074
"the mechanism is available which we on behalf of Mr Carrim proactively offered"
offeredSuliman CarimMr PremhidCL0181098
"Mr Carrim through his doctor is resisting"
resisting examinationSuliman CarimChairpersonCL0181104