WhatTheySaid.co.za The Madlanga Commission record, in plain language

Day 5

23 September 2025

Record: Official record ↗

Who testified

Subjects discussed

👤 Sehlahle Fannie Masemola🏛 National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN (2024/2025 request)👤 Mr. Shadrack Sibiya🏛 South African Police Service👤 Senzo Mchunu (Minister of Police 2024 to 13 July 2025, then placed on special leave)👤 Advocate Terry Motau SC (initial Chief Evidence Leader, Madlanga Commission)👤 Lt Gen Samuel Dumisani Khumalo🏛 Counter and Security Intelligence component

47 conflicts flagged on this day

◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-01fbe8a162e2
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A says team must end in 2025 and cannot go beyond; B confirms extension to 31 March 2026, which exceeds 2025.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the team's lifespan cannot go beyond 2025, it must end in 2025”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“That is correct”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-0a4a40b7650e
Cold Case Unit
Same unit's reporting line differs: Deputy National Commissioner Crime Detection vs Office of the National Commissioner.
Day 62Lieutenant General Sibiya“All of this, including murder and robbery, anti-gang, these are the, that reports to the Deputy National Commissioner, Crime Detection, including cold”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“a unit that has always reported to the Office of the National Commissioner”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-0e6b973a4163
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
Task team cannot be dissolved on 2024-12-31 yet have an extension running 1 Aug 2025 to 31 Mar 2026.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“That is correct”
Day 45Adv Sello SC“the Political Killings Task Team is dissolved, on the 31st of December 2024”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-13afd2ba7647
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Holding a reserved view that it might be illegal is itself a consideration of lawfulness, contradicting claim that lawfulness was not considered.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“I held that view, the reserved view that this might be illegal.”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“it was not considered whether it is lawful or not.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-154eb3c57073
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
Extension runs to 31 March 2026, but B asserts lifespan cannot go beyond 2025; both cannot be true of same team.
Day 5Adv Motau SC“the period 1 August 2025 to 31 March 2026”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the team's lifespan cannot go beyond 2025, it must end in 2025”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-16d8380405f8
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Same letter (MK9) cannot be dated both 31 Jan 2024 and 31 Dec 2024; issuance dates directly contradict.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the letter or the directive was already issued 31st of January 2024”
Day 7Chairperson“letter by Minister Mchunu dated 31 December 2024”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-269ef415766c
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A says it is a task team and explicitly not a unit; B characterizes it as a unit within SAPS—directly contradictory descriptions.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“PKTT is just a task team, not a unit”
“an ad hoc, inter- disciplinary unit within SAPS”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-274d5dbdb590
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A says the task team was disbanded; B says it is present and already performing its function—cannot both be true simultaneously.
Day 79Adv Baloyi SC“the PKTT was disbanded”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“Political Killings Task Team is there already doing the function”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-3e62d68b78c9
Cold Case Unit
A places Cold Case Unit under Deputy National Commissioner Crime Detection; B says it reports directly to National Commissioner—same entity, incompatible reporting lines.
Day 62Lieutenant General Sibiya“All of this, including murder and robbery, anti-gang, these are the, that reports to the Deputy National Commissioner, Crime Detection, including cold”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the Cold Case Unit has been reporting directly to the National Commissioner, since the previous National Commissioner and currently myself”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-3e9a16e85669
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A denies any disbandment/deactivation discussions; B describes a proposal for a phased-out disbandment approach—both cannot be true.
Day 8Lieutenant General Khumalo“There has been no discussions about the deactivation of the Task Team, Political Killings Task Team.”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“The proposal was that there be a phased-out approach to the disbandment”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-3ee4e1b54ef4
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A says no finalised disbandment plan exists; B describes an effective immediate disbandment—cannot both hold for same team.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“there is no finalised disbandment plan”
Day 63Lieutenant General Sibiya“effective immediate in terms of the disbandment”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-3fae3024e448
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A says it requires a defined end period; B says it continues as long as work exists (open-ended)—mutually exclusive on lifespan.
Day 42Minister Senzo Mchunu“It would require a period which would be, at which it will end”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“as long as the work is there, it will go on”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-4c1ec38a6322
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Same letter/directive: Claim A dates issuance 31 Jan 2024, Claim B dates first communication 31 Dec 2024; cannot both be true.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the letter or the directive was already issued 31st of January 2024”
Day 5Adv Motau SC“it starts from the date of 31 December 2024 when it was first communicated”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-4d4d5c4a5778
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
Same extension: one says duration is a year, other says approval is for eight months—incompatible durations.
Day 45Minister Senzo Mchunu“they now say the extension must now take a year”
Day 5Adv Motau SC“the approval for the extension is for eight months”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-55bdbd5780b9
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
Same extension described with different durations: eight months vs six months; cannot both be true.
Day 5Adv Motau SC“the approval for the extension is for eight months”
Day 45Minister Senzo Mchunu“That is why the extension was for another six months”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-613aa6f15035
Cold Case Unit
A says the unit reports directly to the National Commissioner; B says it does not. Same entity, same relationship, mutually exclusive.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the Cold Case Unit has been reporting directly to the National Commissioner, since the previous National Commissioner and currently myself”
Day 62Lieutenant General Sibiya“It is not reporting to the National Commissioner.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-6c672ec382b8
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A says the team was never disbanded; B says a disbandment was still in progress—cannot both be true of same team.
Day 34Major General Motsepe“it was never disbanded”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“we were still with the disbandment plan”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-72d0abd1daf7
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A says agreement was dockets go to province; B says docket was delivered to Pretoria, contradicting the agreed destination.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the agreement was dockets go to province”
“case docket that this office has discovered to have been delivered to Pretoria due to a”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-7847984bfd0c
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A says it continues as long as work exists (open-ended); B says it was never open-ended. Same entity, directly opposing.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“as long as the work is there, it will go on”
Day 42Minister Senzo Mchunu“It was never an open ended”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-878927ef03d5
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A acknowledges a directive to disband the Task Team; B asserts it was never disbanded—contradictory on same entity's status.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“The directive by the Minister of Police to disband the National Task Team has been noted.”
Day 34Major General Motsepe“it was never disbanded”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-8d09b86e522e
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A says team must end in 2025; B seeks extension/budget through 31 March 2026, beyond 2025.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the team's lifespan cannot go beyond 2025, it must end in 2025”
“further extension and provision of a budget for the period 01 August 2025 to 31”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-96e3dbaffa9e
Senzo Mchunu
Claim A dates appointment to 3 July 2024; Claim B says sworn in 3 July 2025—same role, same entity, incompatible dates.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“Minister Mchunu was appointed as a Minister from 3 July 2024”
“Mr Senzo Mchunu was sworn in as the Minister of Police on 3 July 2025.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-b9650675652e
Cold Case Unit
Both claims assert the unit's direct reporting line but name different offices; cannot both be the reporting authority.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“a unit that has always reported to the Office of the National Commissioner”
Day 62Lieutenant General Sibiya“Cold case. It reports to the Deputy National Commissioner, Crime Detection”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-b9dbbae3aa8a
Cold Case Unit
A: signed structure has Unit reporting to Divisional/Deputy National Commissioner; B: Unit reports directly to National Commissioner—same entity, incompatible reporting lines.
Day 62Lieutenant General Sibiya“When you read the structure that is signed by the National Commissioner himself, the structure, the Cold Case Unit, reports to the Deputy National Com”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the Cold Case Unit has been reporting directly to the National Commissioner, since the previous National Commissioner and currently myself”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-c2e5d0794d64
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A says no discussions about deactivating the Task Team; B acknowledges a directive to disband it—cannot both be true.
Day 8Lieutenant General Khumalo“There has been no discussions about the deactivation of the Task Team, Political Killings Task Team.”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“The directive by the Minister of Police to disband the National Task Team has been noted.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-c6a8d46a5320
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
Same extension referent given two different durations: eight months vs another six months, cannot both be true.
Day 5Adv Motau SC“the approval for the extension is for eight months”
Day 45Minister Senzo Mchunu“They say another six months”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-c851341779b6
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A caps lifespan at 2025; B says it continues as long as work exists, implying no fixed end—cannot both hold.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the team's lifespan cannot go beyond 2025, it must end in 2025”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“as long as the work is there, it will go on”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-e00ed5776840
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A says cases determine duration (open-ended); B sets a fixed end in 2025—cannot both govern the same team's lifespan.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the cases will dictate how long the task team is going to be there.”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the team's lifespan cannot go beyond 2025, it must end in 2025”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-e30237e595f2
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A says operations approved until February 2026; B affirms extension runs to 31 March 2026 — different end dates for same body.
“the PKTT's operations have been approved until February 2026”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“That is correct”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-eb19a1d343e2
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A describes the team as investigating 'everything' while B says it deals with 'specific cases'—directly opposing scope claims of same team.
Day 63Lieutenant General Sibiya“you have a unit that is just investigating everything when, in fact, there are units.”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the team is dealing with specific cases, whereas other investigation units are focused on the other cases”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-ecc5d2e4ed98
Cold Case Unit
A says unit always reports to Office of National Commissioner; B says it does not report to National Commissioner—same referent, directly opposed.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“a unit that has always reported to the Office of the National Commissioner”
Day 62Lieutenant General Sibiya“It is not reporting to the National Commissioner.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-efa35590e18a
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A says team dissolved 31 Dec 2024; B anticipates team still working, finishing before end of 2025—cannot both be true.
Day 45Adv Sello SC“the Political Killings Task Team is dissolved, on the 31st of December 2024”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“It is anticipated that the team will complete their work before the end of the year 2025.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-f49333ec207c
Cold Case Unit
Claim A says unit reports directly to National Commissioner; Claim B says it reports to Deputy National Commissioner, Crime Detection—incompatible reporting lines.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the Cold Case Unit has been reporting directly to the National Commissioner, since the previous National Commissioner and currently myself”
Day 62Lieutenant General Sibiya“Cold case. It reports to the Deputy National Commissioner, Crime Detection”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-fe7dc5870fd7
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A denies any discussions about deactivating the Task Team; B admits an ongoing disbandment plan—cannot both be true simultaneously.
Day 8Lieutenant General Khumalo“There has been no discussions about the deactivation of the Task Team, Political Killings Task Team.”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“we were still with the disbandment plan”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-ffca7835d84c
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A asserts the team had to remain (not be disbanded); B says a disbandment plan was still ongoing—contradictory stances on same team.
Day 26Lieutenant General Khumalo“The position has always been that the PKTT had to remain”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“we were still with the disbandment plan”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-16d8380405f8
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Same letter cannot be both issued 31 Jan 2024 and dated 31 Dec 2024; dates are mutually exclusive.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the letter or the directive was already issued 31st of January 2024”
Day 7Chairperson“letter by Minister Mchunu dated 31 December 2024”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-1b942484ef71
Senzo Mchunu
Suspended (disciplinary) and on leave are mutually exclusive employment statuses for the same person at same time.
Day 5Adv Khumalo SC“Minister Mchunu at this point had been suspended”
Day 5Adv Khumalo SC“He is on leave at this point”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-2dcf13216a8b
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A frames disbandment as purely operational within National Commissioner's purview; B insists it cannot legitimately occur without external consultation—incompatible characterizations.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“The decision to disband the PKTT in KZN was fundamentally an operational matter falling squarely within the purview of the National Commissioner”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“such a determination cannot legitimately occur in isolation from a thorough briefings by the relevant SAPS executive and meaningful consultation with ”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-41143cc7c0de
Cedrick Nkabinde
A says participation not usual; B says it is not irregular (i.e., not unusual)—directly opposing characterizations of same participation.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“Not usual”
Day 5Adv Baloyi SC“It is not irregular that he participated”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-61282cdea9e1
Senzo Mchunu
Suspension and leave are distinct, mutually exclusive employment statuses for the same minister at the same point.
Day 5Adv Khumalo SC“Minister Mchunu at this point had been suspended”
Day 5Adv Baloyi SC“He is on leave”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-6d226e4d3a46
Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Police
Claim B says committee was happy with status quo; Claim A says none suggested good work, implying dissatisfaction—same entity, same period.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“There was not one of them, as far as I remember, that suggested that the team should continue or is doing good work.”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“they engaged us and they seem to have been happy with the status that was prevailing at that time.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-8f1389beddb3
Senzo Mchunu
A implies Minister failed to voice/propose action; B says he did intervene and make a determination—can't both be true of same conduct.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“he should at least have said this is what I think we should do”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“When the Minister intervened and made a determination about the PKTT without receiving comprehensive briefing or affording me and the relevant officer”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-c851341779b6
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
Open-ended 'as long as work is there' directly contradicts fixed hard cutoff 'must end in 2025' for same team.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“as long as the work is there, it will go on”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the team's lifespan cannot go beyond 2025, it must end in 2025”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-cac953891021
Senzo Mchunu
Suspension and being on leave are different administrative statuses for the same person at the same time.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“Ja, I think so”
Day 5Adv Baloyi SC“He is on leave”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-ec62951ad45e
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
A says lifespan extends only to 2025; B says operations approved until Feb 2026, contradicting the stated end.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the team go as far as this current – its lifespan goes to as far as this current 2025”
“the PKTT's operations have been approved until February 2026”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-eec3818cc15e
Senzo Mchunu
Suspension and being on leave are different official statuses for the same minister at the same time.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“Ja, I think so”
Day 5Adv Khumalo SC“He is on leave at this point”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-fe7dc5870fd7
National Task Team Investigating Political Related Cases in KZN
Both refer to the same Task Team's disbandment/deactivation; an ongoing disbandment plan cannot coexist with no discussions about deactivation.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“we were still with the disbandment plan”
Day 8Lieutenant General Khumalo“There has been no discussions about the deactivation of the Task Team, Political Killings Task Team.”

Claims from this day

Evidence introduced

ExhibitTitleTypeDate
Index and F. Masemola Annexures_Redacted ↗annexure_bundle23 Sep 2025
Index and F. Masemola Statement ↗witness_statement23 Sep 2025

← All hearing days

Source: criminaljusticecommission.org.za — official transcripts and audio. Protected and pseudonymous witnesses are not identified.

© 2026 Datastroom IT (Pty) Ltd · Published in the public interest · Not affiliated with or endorsed by the Commission