WhatTheySaid.co.za The Madlanga Commission record, in plain language

Day 28

7 November 2025

Record: Official record ↗

Who testified

Subjects discussed

👤 Jabulani Isaac Mapiyeye👤 Deputy Commissioner Revo Spies👤 Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi (suspended EMPD/Metro chief; admits payments from Cat Matlala)🏛 Ekurhuleni Metro Police Department (EMPD) / the City👤 Adv Mahlape Sello SC👤 Mr Xulu👤 Dr Imogen Mashazi👤 three suspended employees (Constable Twala, Officers McKenzie and Stoltz)

16 conflicts flagged on this day

● Certain — deterministic◆ Cross-witness⟂ Independent source
ABS-8131782914e8
Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi
suspension date
2023 vs December 2025 are conflicting suspension years; February is incompatible with December. Genuine conflict on same single suspension date.
FD: suspension_date single-valued (allow-list) + value-typed
Day 28Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye“On the 24th of February, Brigadier Mkhwanazi was placed on suspension with this case of the blue light saga.”
Day 44Commissioner Mkhwanazi“I was suspended 2023”
Day 56Adv Behari (Kemi)“Mr Mkhwanazi was suspended sometimes in February”
Day 57Adv Khumalo SC“He was suspended in December 2025”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-1fdfc1248851
Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi
Same entity's suspension dated to Feb 2023 vs Dec 2025; cannot both be the suspension date.
Day 28Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye“On the 24th of February, Brigadier Mkhwanazi was placed on suspension with this case of the blue light saga.”
Day 57Adv Khumalo SC“He was suspended in December 2025”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-5398ec86a482
Adv Harrison's letter to Lt-Gen Mkhwanazi
Same letter's addressee described as NS Mkhwanazi (Lt-Gen) vs J Mkhwanazi (Director, EMPD) — different name and title, cannot both be true.
“Lieutenant General NS Mkhwanazi”
Day 28Adv Sello SC“It is addressed to J Mkhwanazi, Director: Specialised Services, EMPD”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-7b4cf26435a1
Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi
Claim A dates suspension to 24 Feb over blue light saga; Claim B says December after Commission testimony—incompatible dates/triggers for same person.
Day 28Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye“On the 24th of February, Brigadier Mkhwanazi was placed on suspension with this case of the blue light saga.”
Day 57Adv Khumalo SC“He was suspended in December after testimony in this Commission”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-86c553828280
Deputy Commissioner Revo Spies
Same person's appointment date stated as two different dates: 1 Aug 2022 vs 1 Mar 2025, cannot both be true.
Day 28Commissioner Revo Spies“I was appointed as such on 1 August 2022”
Day 84Commissioner Spies“I was appointed on 1 March 2025”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-8e003117328f
Adv Harrison's letter to Lt-Gen Mkhwanazi
Same letter to Mkhwanazi cannot bear two different dates (22 vs 21 June 2023).
Day 28Adv Sello SC“it is dated the 22nd of June 2023”
Day 56Adv Behari (Kemi)“a letter dated 21 June 2023, addressed to me”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-b37c152bf9b5
Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi
Same suspension event dated to different years: 2023-02-24 vs 2025-02-24; both cannot be the suspension date.
Day 28Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye“On the 24th of February, Brigadier Mkhwanazi was placed on suspension with this case of the blue light saga.”
Day 29Commissioner Revo Spies“starting from February 24th, 2025”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-f0e0be00d02b
Adv Harrison's letter to Lt-Gen Mkhwanazi
Same letter cannot bear two different dates: 2021-02-15 vs 2023-06-22.
“Dale: 2021 ·02· 1 S”
Day 28Adv Sello SC“it is dated the 22nd of June 2023”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-2d4c2f1ef876
Cat Protection and Security Services
A denies any working relationship with EMPD; B affirms active joint crime fighting with EMPD—cannot both be true of same entity.
Day 28Commissioner Revo Spies“there was no working relationship with CAT VIP, according to my knowledge, at all the day when I received this letter”
Day 43Adv Khumalo SC“CAT was in fact doing crime fighting together with EMPD.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-4243ba0d171d
Jabulani Isaac Mapiyeye
Same entity, same WhatsApp message: one claim denies awareness while the other affirms encountering it—cannot both be true.
Day 28Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye“I did not come to the attention of that WhatsApp”
Day 28Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye“I came across that WhatsApp”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-a3b7392d96a6
Mr Magagula
Numerous meetings vs only one meeting with same person cannot both be true.
Day 28Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye“Mr Magagula has had numerous meetings with J Mkhwanazi on sidelines at Boksburg EMPD precinct”
Day 60Mr Magagula“I never had a meeting with Julius Mkhwanazi except this one.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-b223f7d3d13c
Deputy Commissioner Revo Spies
A denies any formal MOUs exist; B affirms multiple signed MOUs over the years—cannot both be true for same entity.
Day 33Kelebogile Thepa“There are no formal MOU’s”
Day 28Commissioner Revo Spies“all the MOUs that we have through the years signed, be it with ACSA, the Airports Company, or with Emperors, or with Cross-Border Permit, or with othe”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-b37c152bf9b5
Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi
Same suspension event dated 2023-02-24 vs 2025-02-24; both cannot be true for same person/event.
Day 28Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye“On the 24th of February, Brigadier Mkhwanazi was placed on suspension with this case of the blue light saga.”
Day 29Commissioner Revo Spies“starting from February 24th, 2025”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-d590e948565f
Jabulani Isaac Mapiyeye
A says no response received from Behari; B says Behari responded next day per document—contradictory about same person's response.
Day 28Chief Mapiyeye“I did not receive any response from both of them.”
Day 28Chief Mapiyeye“I have came across a document where Kemi Behari responded the following day”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-e4d5d7a76696
Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi
One says promoted to Deputy Chief, other says became Chief of Police; different ranks for same person cannot both hold.
Day 28Adv Khumalo SC“Brigadier Mkhwanazi was in fact promoted to the position of Deputy Chief of Police”
Day 28Adv Khumalo SC“He became Chief of Police in December of 2023”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
XW-c02d29cb89bd
Mr Xulu
returned to
He returned to Gauteng vs returned to KZN; incompatible single locations.
Day 28Adv Sello SC“he subsequently came back”
Day 28Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye“he then went back where he came from”

Claims from this day

← All hearing days

Source: criminaljusticecommission.org.za — official transcripts and audio. Protected and pseudonymous witnesses are not identified.

© 2026 Datastroom IT (Pty) Ltd · Published in the public interest · Not affiliated with or endorsed by the Commission