WhatTheySaid.co.za The Madlanga Commission record, in plain language

Day 2

18 September 2025

Record: Official record ↗

Who testified

Subjects discussed

👤 Lt Gen Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi👤 Adv Mahlape Sello SC👤 Fadiel Adams🏛 SAPS National Inspectorate division🏛 task team (as organisational category)👤 John Mokgatle👤 Senzo Chief (Chief of Staff)👤 Mr Vusimuzi 'Cat' Matlala

34 conflicts flagged on this day

◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-065d87f114ae
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Same document dated differently: 2019 generation vs 31 December 2024 signing date cannot both be the document's date.
Day 2Adv Sello SC“this is generated in 2019”
Day 2Adv Sello SC“it is the 31st of December”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-0758cd8f48ac
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Same letter cannot be both generated in 2019 and dated 31 December 2024.
Day 2Adv Sello SC“this is generated in 2019”
Day 7Chairperson“letter by Minister Mchunu dated 31 December 2024”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-0f7c7e8bba08
email from Mr Adams to the Minister on 1 November 2024
A says email sent via intermediary Ms Frenchman; B says sent directly to Minister—same email cannot be both via and direct.
Day 163Adv Segeels-Ncube“you send an email to the Minister via Ms Frenchman”
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“He sent an email directly to the Minister”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-1815334ba82f
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Same document (MK9): Claim A says generated in 2019, Claim B says dated/dispatched 31 Dec 2024 — dates cannot both be true.
Day 2Adv Sello SC“this is generated in 2019”
Day 2Adv Sello SC“it is dispatched to the office of General Masemola as the National Commissioner on the same date”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-364fc2aaee8a
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Same document dated 31-12-2024 cannot also be generated in 2019; conflicting dates for same entity.
Day 2Adv Sello SC“this is generated in 2019”
Day 4Lieutenant General Masemola“dated 31-12-2024”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-38d4e2306828
Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi
A attributes suspension to city action from Premier's questions; B attributes it to principal blocking his investigation—incompatible causes for same suspension.
Day 57Adv Behari (Kemi)“he was suspended as a result of the action being taken by the city, arising out of questions posed by the Premier”
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“he was suspended because the principal at the Municipality did not want him to pursue this investigation against his junior”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-3fb156d593f9
email from Mr Adams to the Minister on 1 November 2024
One says email sent via Ms Frenchman as intermediary; other says sent directly to the Minister—same email cannot be both.
Day 163Adv Segeels-Ncube“you send an email to the Minister via Ms Frenchman”
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“the first one was directly to the Minister of police”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-40f4d61759fc
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Same letter cannot be generated in 2019 and dated 31 Dec 2024; the two dates for the same document conflict.
Day 2Adv Sello SC“this is generated in 2019”
Day 2Adv Sello SC“the letter is dated the 31st of December 2024”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-5f38021111ee
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
A expects understanding will emerge by document's end; B says only the writer can ever understand it—mutually exclusive prospects for same letter.
Day 2Adv Sello SC“I hope by the time we get to the conclusion of this document, perhaps then we will have a better understanding”
Day 26Lieutenant General Khumalo“the only person who can understand the letter is the writer himself”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-70867fb3ee60
Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi
A denies any knowledge of blue lights and says City doesn't issue them; B says he caused the Municipality to take/issue blue lights—cannot both be true.
Day 91Commissioner Mkhwanazi“I know nothing about blue lights and I have been consistent about that the City does not issue blue lights.”
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“He took these vehicles and he caused the Municipality to take the blue lights that belongs to the Municipality”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-7870ae63719a
email from Mr Adams to the Minister on 1 November 2024
Two sources date the same email differently: 4 November vs 1 November 2024, cannot both be true.
“(dated 4”
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“It is 08:21:01 in the morning of the 1st of November 2024”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-7a299c79b5da
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Same letter (MK9) assigned two different dates: 31 Jan 2024 vs 31 Dec; cannot both be true of one document.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the letter or the directive was already issued 31st of January 2024”
Day 2Adv Sello SC“it is the 31st of December”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-89463bf2c015
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
A attributes the document to Cele; B states it was signed by Mchunu—different authors of same letter cannot both be true.
Day 2Chairperson“this is the Minister's document”
Day 4Lieutenant General Masemola“It was sincerely signed, Minister of Police, Mr ES Mchunu MP”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-8abdbc19bd5c
Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi
A denies any involvement in vehicle registration; B asserts he facilitated the registration—directly incompatible about same act.
Day 57Adv Baloyi SC“Mkhwanazi has nothing to do with that”
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“He facilitated the registration of this Mr Matlala’s vehicles under the Municipality as if they are Municipality official vehicles”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-9025f52f3e41
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Same letter (MK9) cannot bear two different issuance dates: Jan 31 2024 vs Dec 31 2024.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the letter or the directive was already issued 31st of January 2024”
Day 2Adv Sello SC“the letter is dated the 31st of December 2024”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-9ef9896d585e
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Same letter dated 31 December vs issued 31 January 2024 — different dates cannot both be true.
Day 2Adv Khumalo SC“It is in fact dated 31 December”
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the letter or the directive was already issued 31st of January 2024”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-c226734a06e1
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Same MK9 letter cannot be issued 31 Jan 2024 and dated/dispatched 31 Dec 2024; entity fixed date contradicts issuance claim.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the letter or the directive was already issued 31st of January 2024”
Day 2Adv Sello SC“it is dispatched to the office of General Masemola as the National Commissioner on the same date”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-dcc9ece90afc
Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi
A states he was suspended; B states not suspended—directly contradictory on same suspension status.
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“he was suspended because the principal at the Municipality did not want him to pursue this investigation against his junior”
Day 31Mr Nciza“The person is not suspended, you know”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-e3c783e5c324
email from Mr Adams to the Minister on 1 November 2024
Same email dated differently: information note says 4 November 2024 vs 1 November 2024; both cannot be true of same email.
“(dated 4”
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“the 1st of November 2024”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-e81819b39a31
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Same letter dated as generated in 2019 vs referred to as 2 January 2025; incompatible dating of one document.
Day 2Adv Sello SC“this is generated in 2019”
Day 2Adv Khumalo SC“We kept referring to it as the 2 January 2025 letter”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-f952fbf2461d
Annexure MK9 — disestablishment letter signed by Minister Mchunu, date
Same MK9 letter given incompatible dates: issued 31 Jan 2024 vs referred to as 2 Jan 2025 letter; cannot both be true.
Day 5Lieutenant General Masemola“the letter or the directive was already issued 31st of January 2024”
Day 2Adv Khumalo SC“We kept referring to it as the 2 January 2025 letter”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-4497d5b95cc5
Independent Police Investigative Directorate
A says IPID produced a report making recommendations to Ekurhuleni municipality; B says IPID lacks authority to make suggestions to a municipality. Same entity, directly contradictory.
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“there is a report that IPID produced to Ekurhuleni, a report that makes recommendations to the Executive of Ekurhuleni”
Day 32Mr Nciza“They would not have authority to make suggestions to a municipality.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-4ebc8856d5de
Annexure MK15
Same document MK15 characterized as an information note vs. a report in its entirety; mutually exclusive descriptions of same entity.
Day 2Adv Sello SC“that is Annexure MK15. It is that information note from the Inspectorate”
Day 141Advocate Sello SC“it is actually a report in its entirety.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-617aac68c140
Suliman Carim
One claims a relationship with the Minister exists; the other denies any relationship — directly contradictory about same referent.
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“he has this relationship with the Minister”
Day 73Mr Carrim“you have no relationship with the Minister”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-6eec2cc29dfc
Suliman Carim
One claims he has a relationship with the Minister; the other claims no connection or access to the Minister—mutually exclusive.
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“he has this relationship with the Minister”
Day 73Mr Carrim“Yes.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-79f86b53f8b8
SAPS National Inspectorate division
One states the Inspectorate remains within the Police structure; the other states it was removed—mutually exclusive for same entity.
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“Inspectorate remains within the structure of the Police.”
Day 42Minister Senzo Mchunu“It is the removal of Police Inspectorate, which was a unit”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-95669b611050
Investigative Directorate Against Corruption
Claim A says correspondence excludes those in charge; Claim B says it includes the head of IDAC—same correspondence, contradictory inclusion.
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“the correspondence from the NPA to the Police does not include the people in charge of the two entities.”
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“It includes the head of IDAC and the head of investigation.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-a7d57ad7387d
Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi
Same entity, same action: one says he fitted/installed blue lights, the other denies installing them—directly contradictory.
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“he fitted those blue lights in these vehicles”
Day 43Commissioner Mkhwanazi“I did not instal blue lights.”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-aa3145aa77f2
media article 'Breaking news. NPA ID guns for National Police rogue un
Same role (National Police Commissioner Masemola) given conflicting first names: Jerry vs Fannie.
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“The National Police Commissioner, Jerry Masemola appeared weak and shaken when confronted by the ID”
“national police commissioner Fannie Masemola”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-aba39bbd68a9
John Mokgatle
One claim states he reported on duty; the other states he was not on duty and not supposed to be there—directly opposed.
Day 2Johannes Magatle“he reported on duty”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-d29f7471ca6d
media article 'Breaking news. NPA ID guns for National Police rogue un
Same role (National Police Commissioner Masemola) given contradictory first names: Fannie vs Jerry.
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“The NPA Investigative Directorate, ID, raids National Police Commissioner Fannie Masemola and National Crime Intelligence Head, Lt Gen Khumalo’s offic”
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“The National Police Commissioner, Jerry Masemola appeared weak and shaken when confronted by the ID”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-f12a23467f7e
SAPS National Inspectorate division
One says the Inspectorate remains within Police structure; the other says the whole unit was disestablished—cannot both be true.
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“Inspectorate remains within the structure of the Police.”
Day 42Minister Senzo Mchunu“We did it, the whole unit in the organizational structure”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-f36491d400e7
SAPS National Inspectorate division
Same entity cannot both remain within Police structure and be disestablished simultaneously.
Day 2Lt Gen Mkhwanazi“Inspectorate remains within the structure of the Police.”
Day 42Minister Senzo Mchunu“we are agreeing to disestablish the Police Inspectorate”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-f6e3b423ee22
Annexure MK15
Same annexure MK15 identified as both General Jacobs's report and an Inspectorate information note—incompatible document identities.
Day 2Adv Sello SC“the report of General Jacobs is Annexure MK15 to General Mkhwanazi's statement”
Day 2Adv Sello SC“that is Annexure MK15. It is that information note from the Inspectorate”

Claims from this day

Evidence introduced

ExhibitTitleTypeDate
Legal Team Opening Address ↗other_submission18 Sep 2025

← All hearing days

Source: criminaljusticecommission.org.za — official transcripts and audio. Protected and pseudonymous witnesses are not identified.

© 2026 Datastroom IT (Pty) Ltd · Published in the public interest · Not affiliated with or endorsed by the Commission